Comments Required for Audio Profiles?

Category: Zone BBS Suggestions and Feedback

Post 1 by OceanDream (An Ocean of Thoughts) on Monday, 16-Aug-2010 8:49:28

I've come to the conclusion lately that many people like to review audio profiles, but don't give any reason behind the number they decide to select in the combo box. Therefore, that's just what it looks like; a random number, so I really think if you're going to go to the trouble of reviewing a profile, you should be required to at least fill out the comment field. If you don't want to include a subject, fine, because that seems to be the case for posting comments elsewhere, but I would kind of like to know the reason behind the 5 rating, or the 7 rating. Isn't the reason for the reviews supposed to be constructive?

Post 2 by chelslicious (like it or not, I'm gonna say what I mean. all the time.) on Monday, 16-Aug-2010 8:55:09

I agree with you completely; I think that's a great suggestion.

Post 3 by Twinklestar09 (I've now got the bronze prolific poster award! now going for the silver award!) on Monday, 16-Aug-2010 11:18:46

I like that idea also.

Post 4 by nikos (English words from a Greek thinking brain) on Sunday, 22-Aug-2010 16:36:03

I have to say that when i give 10 for example to somebody most of the time i don't write comments but i guess 10 doesn't need much explanation it is the highest number somebody can give to a profile so it means that i like it.
But if i give 8 or a lower number i will probably explain why for example i might say that there is distortion or the volumes are high or low etc.
But i think it is a good suggestion.

Post 5 by AgateRain (Believe it or not, everything on me and about me is real!) on Sunday, 22-Aug-2010 17:07:35

Um, yeah good suggestion and I don't care for the number just the comments because I like to know how I sound and so on.

Post 6 by Blue Velvet (I've got the platinum golden silver bronze poster award.) on Sunday, 22-Aug-2010 20:33:13

How on earth would such a requirement be enforced?

Post 7 by GreenTurtle (Music is life. Love. Vitality.) on Monday, 23-Aug-2010 0:57:39

That's easy, just put a star before the field so it's required, and it won't let you submit the form unless you fill it out.

Post 8 by OceanDream (An Ocean of Thoughts) on Monday, 23-Aug-2010 10:29:19

Exactly. It shouldn't be too hard to code.

Post 9 by illumination (Darkness is history.) on Monday, 23-Aug-2010 12:34:45

I actually like this suggestion. I've experienced the same thing.